Right of First Refusal in Real Estate: How It Works
A right of first refusal in real estate lets its holder match an outside offer before the owner sells. How it works, ROFR vs option, and state rules.
A right of first refusal in real estate gives its holder the first chance to buy a property before the owner sells it to someone else, usually by matching the price and terms of an outside offer the owner is ready to accept. It does not force the owner to sell, and it is not an option to buy.
Pillar, a land research software company, wrote this guide. Each statute and court opinion below links to its source, checked on November 17, 2026. The law differs by state and by the wording of each agreement, so each rule is an example from the state named. This is general information, not legal advice; have a real estate attorney licensed in the property's state read the document.
What is a right of first refusal in real estate?
A right of first refusal (often shortened to ROFR) is an owner's promise not to sell to anyone else without first offering the property to the holder. The Texas Supreme Court's definition, in Archer v. Tregellas (2018), quoting its earlier Tenneco decision: "A right of first refusal, also known as a preemptive or preferential right, empowers its holder with a preferential right to purchase the subject property on the same terms offered by or to a bona fide purchaser."
Louisiana puts it in its Civil Code. Under article 2625, "A party may agree that he will not sell a certain thing without first offering it to a certain person."
The holder gets a place in line, not a price and not a date. If the owner never sells, the holder never gets to buy.
How does a right of first refusal work?
The agreement that creates the right controls the details. Most follow four steps.
- The trigger. The owner decides to sell and receives an outside offer the owner is willing to accept.
- The notice. The owner tells the holder and offers the property on the outside buyer's terms. Archer says the right generally requires the owner "to notify the holder of his intent to sell."
- The time to match. The clause sets a deadline. Where the parties have not agreed on one, Louisiana supplies it: the offer must be accepted within thirty days from the time it is received if the thing is immovable, and within ten days if it is movable.
- Match or pass. If the holder accepts, the holder buys on those terms. If the holder declines or the deadline passes, the owner may sell to the outside buyer. In Louisiana, the right "subsists" in a holder who passed unless the owner concludes a final sale, or a contract to sell, with a third person within six months.
A worked example (hypothetical)
The names, dates and prices here are made up to show the sequence.
- The right. A farmer sold 10 acres to a neighbor in 2020. The recorded deed gave the farmer a right of first refusal, with 30 days to match after written notice.
- March 2. A builder signs a contract to buy the 10 acres from the neighbor for $400,000 cash. Closing depends on the farmer waiving the right or the deadline passing.
- March 8. The farmer receives a full copy of the signed contract. The 30 days end April 7.
- If the farmer matches by April 7. The farmer buys for $400,000 on the same terms. The builder's contract ends, and the builder has spent its study costs on land it will not get.
- If the farmer passes. The farmer signs a waiver, or April 7 passes with no answer. The neighbor may then sell to the builder on those terms.
Right of first refusal vs right of first offer vs option to purchase
These three get confused, and the difference decides who controls the sale.
- Right of first refusal. The outside buyer sets the price, unless the agreement fixes another method. The owner starts the process by deciding to sell. The owner cannot be forced to sell: New York's highest court, in LIN Broadcasting v. Metromedia (1989), said the right does not "give its holder the power to compel an unwilling owner to sell."
- Right of first offer. The owner goes to the holder first, before any outside buyer is involved. A 2018 Florida Bar Journal article describes it as "offering the property to the rights holder before it is offered to the general public." A Texas A&M Real Estate Research Center article says the holder "has the right to make an offer that the owner may or may not accept."
- Option to purchase. The option fixes the price, and the holder starts the process. In Louisiana, an option "must set forth the thing and the price" and gives the holder the right to accept within a stipulated time. The owner can be forced to sell: LIN Broadcasting describes an option as creating "a power to compel an unwilling seller to sell at the agreed price."
States differ on what happens once the right is triggered. Texas courts say that when the owner communicates the terms, the right "ripens into an enforceable option," a phrase Archer quotes from a Texas appellate decision. LIN Broadcasting, a dispute over partnership and stock interests rather than land, went the other way: the agreements did not make the offer irrevocable, so the owner could withdraw it before the holder accepted once the outside sale was abandoned.
Does a right of first refusal have to be in writing or recorded?
In writing. In New York, generally yes. An appellate court held in McCormick v. Bechtol (2009) that "A right of first refusal is subject to the statute of frauds," citing General Obligations Law § 5-703(2). That subdivision makes a contract for the sale of any real property, or an interest in it, void unless the contract or a note or memorandum of it, "expressing the consideration," is in writing and subscribed by the party to be charged or by a lawful agent authorized in writing. A signed writing was not enough in McCormick: the written right failed because it did not state the price if the owner sold only one of the two parcels. Subdivision 4 leaves courts of equity the power "to compel the specific performance of agreements in cases of part performance." Texas has a similar statute of frauds: Business and Commerce Code § 26.01 makes "a contract for the sale of real estate" unenforceable unless it, or a memorandum of it, is in writing and signed by the person to be charged or by someone lawfully authorized to sign for that person.
Recorded. Recording is about later buyers. Two states handle it this way:
- Louisiana. A right of first refusal on immovable property "is effective against third persons only from the time the instrument that contains it is filed for registry in the parish where the immovable is located."
- Texas. An instrument that is properly recorded in the proper county is "notice to all persons of the existence of the instrument." Archer says a person who buys "with actual or constructive notice of a right of first refusal takes the property subject to that right," and, quoting an earlier Texas decision, that such a buyer "may be compelled to convey title" to the holder.
How long does a right of first refusal last?
As long as the agreement says, up to the limit state law allows.
- Louisiana. A right of first refusal on immovable property "may not be granted for a term longer than ten years," and a longer term "shall be reduced to ten years." The exception is a right granted with a contract of continuous or periodic performance, which may last as long as that performance requires.
- Massachusetts. For interests created after June 30, 1990, General Laws chapter 184A, § 5 says "a preemptive right in the nature of a right of first refusal in gross with respect to an interest in land or minerals becomes invalid if it is not exercised within thirty years after its creation." Under § 5(d), the limit is fifty years for a right held by a government or government agency or subdivision, a public instrumentality or public authority, a quasi-public entity, or an instrumentality created under chapter 40F. For a right in a deed recorded in 1981, which had no end date and let the holder buy on the terms of a bona fide offer, the state's high court held in Bortolotti v. Hayden (2007) that it was "neither void under the rule against perpetuities nor a restriction constituting an unreasonable restraint on alienation."
- New York. In Morrison v. Piper (1990), the Court of Appeals held that the state's rule against remote vesting applies to a first refusal right "created in a deed conveying noncommercial, residential property between private parties." The right in that case survived because, as the court read the deed, it could be exercised only during the lives of the two original parties, an aunt and her nephew, by either of them or by that party's direct donees or beneficiaries, whose own rights were personal and could not be assigned.
Can a right of first refusal be waived?
Yes. The holder can decline in writing or let the deadline pass. The Texas A&M article suggests clause language under which, if the holder does not respond in time, the right "is deemed waived and a third party may rely on owner's recorded affidavit to that effect." Some agreements require a recordable release instead. Read the clause to see whether the right ends after one pass or continues for later sales.
Where rights of first refusal show up
- Leases. In Hartzheim v. Valley Land & Cattle Co. (2007), a California lease gave the tenant the right to buy if the landlord obtained "a bona fide offer from any third party" that the landlord proposed to accept.
- Deeds between family members and neighbors. Morrison involved an aunt who conveyed 2.3 acres of family lakefront land to her nephew, with first refusal rights written into the deed.
- Co-owner agreements. The Texas A&M article says the right is generally "between or among co-owners or cotenants."
- Condominium documents. For new and newly converted condo projects with more than four units, Fannie Mae requires that any right of first refusal in the project documents "will not adversely impact the rights of a mortgagee or its assignee" to foreclose, take a deed in lieu, or resell the unit.
- Tenant purchase statutes. In Washington, D.C., before selling a housing accommodation, an owner must give the tenant "an opportunity to purchase the housing accommodation at a price and terms that represent a bona fide offer of sale." A tenant or tenant organization also has a right of first refusal "during the 15 days after the tenant or tenant organization has received from the owner a valid sales contract to purchase by a third party." If the contract is received during a negotiation period under § 42-3404.09(c)(4), § 42-3404.10(a)(2) or § 42-3404.11(2), the 15 days start when that period ends. These rights do not apply to single-family accommodations except as § 42-3404.09 provides. It covers tenants who were elderly or disabled on the offer-of-sale date, signed rental agreements by March 31, 2018 and took occupancy by April 15, 2018. They also do not apply to a tenant who "begins occupying a housing accommodation after the issuance of an offer of sale." Read the current code for eligibility and timing.
Common disputes over a right of first refusal
- Package deals. In FWT, Inc. v. Haskin Wallace Mason Property Management (2009), an outside offer tied about six acres to the purchase of other business assets. A Texas appeals court held the tie was "commercially reasonable, imposed in good faith, and not specifically designed to defeat" the right, so the holder could not buy the land alone.
- Family transfers. In Hartzheim, a family partnership moved the leased land to the partners' grandchildren as part of estate planning. The California court held that "this particular intrafamily transfer did not trigger the right of first refusal" because there was no bona fide third-party offer to purchase, which the lease required.
- No notice. In Archer, the owners sold a mineral interest without telling the holders of a recorded right, who learned of it more than four years later. The Texas Supreme Court held that the discovery rule applied to the four-year limitations period and reinstated the trial court's judgment, which ordered the buyer to convey the interest to the holders once they deposited the price.
Buying or developing land subject to a right of first refusal
For a land buyer, someone else's right of first refusal means you can negotiate a contract, pay for studies, and then lose the land to a holder who matches your terms. The Florida Bar Journal article says a refusal right "will typically adversely affect the owner's ability to sell the burdened property as long as the refusal right is outstanding."
Where it shows up
- The title commitment. A recorded right should be found in the title search. As we read the standard form, it would then be listed among the Schedule B exceptions. Our guide to reading a title commitment covers each schedule.
- The deed and the chain of title. The right may sit in a deed from decades ago, as in Bortolotti. A chain of title search can find a recorded one; read every deed in the chain, along with any recorded deed restrictions.
- Leases. A lease can contain the right, as in Hartzheim. Ask the seller for every lease and written agreement affecting the land, recorded or not.
What to check before an offer
- Ask the seller in writing whether anyone holds a right of first refusal, right of first offer or option on the land.
- Get the document and read the trigger, the notice method, the deadline, and whether the right survives a pass. Note how long the holder has to respond: the Bortolotti deed allowed 20 days.
- If your offer bundles other parcels or assets, ask an attorney how the state's courts treat package offers.
- Ask your attorney how to condition the contract on a valid waiver or on the response period ending, and when to spend on studies.
- Confirm the holder was sent the full terms. Archer shows that a holder who was never notified may be able to sue the buyer years later.
For the wider process, see how to buy land. If the seller is financing the sale, see our guide to the land contract.
Quick answers
What does right of first refusal mean in real estate? The holder gets the first chance to buy before the owner sells to someone else, usually by matching an outside offer.
Is a right of first refusal the same as an option to purchase? No. An option lets the holder force a sale at an agreed price. A right of first refusal applies only if the owner decides to sell.
What is the difference between a right of first refusal and a right of first offer? With a first offer right, the owner goes to the holder before marketing the property. With a first refusal right, the holder responds to an outside offer.
Does a right of first refusal have to be recorded? In Louisiana it binds third persons only once it is filed in the parish records. In Texas a buyer with notice, including notice from a recorded instrument, takes subject to the right.
How long does a right of first refusal last? It depends on the agreement and the state. Louisiana caps it at ten years for immovable property, with one exception. In Massachusetts, unexercised rights in gross created after June 30, 1990 generally become invalid after thirty years; § 5(d) covers specified public holders.